{"store":{"baseInfo":{"podcastTitle":"The Overthinkers","slug":"therealoverthinkers","podcastDescription":"A place where you can have fun thinking deeply about all the big and beautiful questions of life complete with cutaways. Hosts Joseph Holmes and Nathan Clarkson explore subjects of art, faith, philosophy, culture, and more with some of today’s leading and most influential minds and figures. So put your thinking caps and your laughing socks on and come on in!","podcastLogo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/8231187/The_Overthinkers_1__c5f8kn.png","podcastShareLogo":"https://d2bwo9zemjwxh5.cloudfront.net/image-logo/8231187/The_Overthinkers_1__c5f8kn_1200x628.jpg?s=63c1132065c289ed2a6ae85faec54ddb&e=png","podcastUrl":"https://therealoverthinkers.podbean.com","podcastCanSearched":true,"feedUrl":"https://feed.podbean.com/therealoverthinkers/feed.xml","theme":"elegant","podcastDeepLink":"https://www.podbean.com/pw/pbblog-45gnp-7d9913?from=usersite","removePodbeanBranding":"no","brandingLogo":null,"timeZone":{"timeZoneId":5,"gmtAdjustment":"GMT-08:00","useDaylightTime":1,"value":-8,"text":"(GMT-08:00) Pacific Time (US & Canada)","daylightStartTime":"Second Sunday Of March +2 Hours","daylightEndTime":"First Sunday Of November +2 Hours","timezone":"America/Los_Angeles"},"podcastDownloads":null,"totalEpisodes":257,"showComments":true,"iOSAppDownloadLink":null,"customizeCssUrl":null,"androidAppDownloadLink":null,"showPostShare":true,"showLike":true,"author":"Nathan Clarkson & Joseph Holmes","enableEngagementStats":true,"shareEmbedLink":"https://admin5.podbean.com/embed.html?id=pbblog-45gnp-7d9913-playlist","language":"en","sensitivitySessionExpireTime":3600,"podcastApps":[{"name":"Apple Podcasts","link":"https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-overthinkers/id1510271421","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/apple-podcast.png","title":null},{"name":"Podbean App","link":"https://www.podbean.com/pw/pbblog-45gnp-7d9913?from=usersite","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/podbean-app.png","title":null},{"name":"Spotify","link":"https://open.spotify.com/show/7bagdh5GxLkpdWk7Q9h4yS","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/spotify.png","title":null},{"name":"Amazon Music","link":"https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/cbc0bf5e-8fb2-42be-bb08-f6462218b8e5","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/AmazonMusic.png","title":null}],"components":{"base":[{"id":"MainStyle","val":"dark"},{"id":"Font","val":"Avenir"},{"id":"SecondaryFont","val":"Avenir"},{"id":"PlayerColor","val":"#8fc31f"},{"id":"PlayerStyle","val":"player1"},{"id":"PlayerWave","val":"show"},{"id":"Favicon","val":null},{"id":"CookiesNotice","val":"hide"},{"id":"CookiesNoticeContent","val":"

Cookies Notice

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies.

"}],"home-header":[{"id":"HomeHeaderTextColor","val":"#ffffff"},{"id":"HomeHeaderBackgroundColor","val":"#000000"}],"page-header":[{"id":"PageHeaderTextColor","val":"#ffffff"},{"id":"PageHeaderBackgroundColor","val":"#171717"}],"episode-list":[{"id":"EpisodeListType","val":"list"},{"id":"EpisodesPerPage","val":10},{"id":"EpisodeStats","val":"hide"}],"navigation":[{"id":"NavigationFontColor","val":"#ffffff"},{"id":"NavigationBackgroundColor","val":"#000000"},{"id":"NavigationSearch","val":"show"},{"id":"NavigationLinks","val":[{"id":"Home","type":"Link","value":"/","text":"Home","subitems":[]},{"id":"Subscribe","type":"Link","value":"https://www.podbean.com/site/podcatcher/index/blog/9jNapkC07ul1","text":"Subscribe","subitems":[]},{"id":"Profile","type":"Link","value":"https://www.podbean.com/user-3aRGK7cMoSJx","text":"Profile","subitems":[]}]}],"footer":[{"id":"FooterType","val":"Footer2"},{"id":"FooterFontColor","val":"#ffffff"},{"id":"FooterBackgroundColor","val":"#000000"},{"id":"FooterCopyright","val":"Copyright 2020 All rights reserved."},{"id":"SocialMediaLinks","val":{"facebook_username":"","twitter_username":"","instagram_username":"","youtube_username":"","linkedin_username":""}}],"customize-container1":[],"customize-container2":[{"id":"ComponentImageText2-1","val":{"ComponentFontColor":"#dfdfdf","ComponentBackgroundColor":"#1a1a1a","ComponentImage":"https://mcdn.podbean.com/mf/web/6j2ecn/553DA0DF-2BFA-4F24-A662-B87A79430B72_1_4338db3e-0886-346c-34af-0cb45d185ba0.png","ComponentContent":"

The Show

A home for the creative intellectual who wants to have fun thinking deeply. Through interviews with influential and interesting guests; The Overthinkers ask the big and beautiful life-questions about faith, philosophy, art, culture, and humanity. Come and join the often deep and always hilarious conversation.

"}}]},"allLinks":[],"mainStylesDefaultSettings":null,"defaultCustomizeComponents":null,"scripts":[],"metas":null,"appConfig":{"package":"com.podbean.app.podcast","app_store_id":973361050,"app_name":"Podbean","scheme":"podbean"},"customizeCss":null,"canEditCss":null,"enableJsCodeInCustomizeContent":false,"enabledIframeCodeInCustomizeContent":true,"sectionMaxCount":10,"enableEditorLink":true,"enableEditCookiesNotice":true,"siteRedirectToFeed":false,"podcatcherRssUrl":null,"showFeed":true,"showTopBar":true,"enableWebSiteLike":true,"organizationName":null,"organizationPageLink":null},"backToListUrl":"/","tinymceLoaded":false,"listEpisodes":[],"userLikedEpisodes":[],"userLikeCheckedEpisodes":[],"topBarIframeLoaded":false,"listTotalCount":0,"listTotalPage":0,"listPage":0,"listType":"all","listValue":"","listName":"","pageLoading":false,"apiBaseUrl":"https://therealoverthinkers.podbean.com","apiCommonParams":{"t":"684f97f4","clientSignature":"ed9d6fd0e89f041c1c417b72a53c49d1","u":null,"customizing":null},"apiCommonHeaders":{},"comments":[{"id":"g2hmfx26xbh4","userLink":"https://www.podbean.com/user-zJ0RMLH85TV2","userImage":"//pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/10364442/AOh14Gib_CvLsy6Vv2I6wVqtnUxbBJPBYETqDt2Lih7O=s96-c.jpg","isVip":false,"nickName":"lrlaurennoelle","content":"Thank you for this podcast!!!! It’s water for my soul ","hasParentComment":"","parentCommentLink":null,"parentCommentNickName":null,"parentCommentContent":null,"hasEpisode":true,"episodeLink":"https://therealoverthinkers.podbean.com/e/where-do-our-christmas-traditions-come-from-with-louis-giovino/","episodeTitle":"Where Do Our Christmas Traditions Come From? (With Louis Giovino)","createTime":"4 years ago","commentTimestamp":1607296688,"likedCount":0,"replyCount":0,"parentCommentId":"","replyCommentId":null,"encryptedUserId":"zJ0RMLH85TV2"}],"commentsTotalCount":1,"commentsTotalPage":1,"commentsPage":1,"commentEpisodeId":"pb15964959-vfsrd","episode":{"id":"pb15964959","idTag":"vfsrd","title":"Where Do Our Christmas Traditions Come From? (With Louis Giovino)","logo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/8231187/The_Overthinkers_1__c5f8kn_300x300.png","shareLogo":"https://d2bwo9zemjwxh5.cloudfront.net/image-logo/8231187/The_Overthinkers_1__c5f8kn_1200x628.jpg?s=63c1132065c289ed2a6ae85faec54ddb&e=png","largeLogo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/8231187/The_Overthinkers_1__c5f8kn.png","previewContent":null,"content":"

Joseph Holmes and Nathan Clarkson welcome back resident church and theology history buff Louis Giovino to discuss whether our modern Christmas traditions are more Christian or secular in origin, and whether or not that matters.

","publishTimestamp":1606688749,"duration":3406,"mediaUrl":"https://mcdn.podbean.com/mf/web/cncwsn/Episode_32_-_Draft_1awijz.mp3","mediaType":"audio/mpeg","shareLink":"https://admin5.podbean.com/embed.html?id=pb-vfsrd-f39b1f","likedCount":null,"deepLink":"https://www.podbean.com/ew/pb-vfsrd-f39b1f","transcriptUrl":null,"permalink":"/e/where-do-our-christmas-traditions-come-from-with-louis-giovino/","downloadLink":"https://www.podbean.com/media/share/pb-vfsrd-f39b1f?download=1","fallbackResource":null,"fallbackResourceMimetype":null,"downloadCount":0,"status":"publish","hasMoreContent":false,"chaptersUrl":null,"explicit":false},"episodeShareLink":null,"deepLink":"https://www.podbean.com/ew/pb-vfsrd-f39b1f","playlist":{"episodes":[],"current":0,"start":0,"stop":0,"playing":true,"playerLoading":true,"playbackRate":1,"playbackRateIndex":1},"toasts":[],"confirm":null,"customizeEditorFormZIndex":999,"lastRequestTime":null,"validateChangesOnBeforeunload":true,"windowWidth":1000,"VITE_FS1_CDN_URL_PREFIX":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1","reloadStats":false,"userIdEncrypted":null,"userProfilePicture":null,"username":null,"isVerified":false,"loadUserInfo":false,"loginUrl":"https://www.podbean.com/site/user/login?return=https%253A%252F%252Ftherealoverthinkers.podbean.com%252Fe%252Fwhere-do-our-christmas-traditions-come-from-with-louis-giovino%252F&rts=7cadde271de2f11825b59c62a0d0e4b7cb9e72fd","recaptchaV3Loaded":false,"recaptchaV2Loaded":false,"likesLoaded":false,"commentLikeMap":{},"commentOffset":0},"episode":{"id":"pb15964959","idTag":"vfsrd","title":"Where Do Our Christmas Traditions Come From? (With Louis Giovino)","logo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/8231187/The_Overthinkers_1__c5f8kn_300x300.png","shareLogo":"https://d2bwo9zemjwxh5.cloudfront.net/image-logo/8231187/The_Overthinkers_1__c5f8kn_1200x628.jpg?s=63c1132065c289ed2a6ae85faec54ddb&e=png","largeLogo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/8231187/The_Overthinkers_1__c5f8kn.png","previewContent":null,"content":"